italian car accessoriesHis wife was awarded 400000 had signed a couple violence

cxa2re08x

marriedcouple  signed the  agreement  husband and wife  ,later  wife  repeated  domestic violence  ,unbearable  divorce  .after  the  huge compensation  agreement  effective  ?this  is  the law  issue  ,recently  had a  precedent  .
after 3  years in  the 3 trial  ,the guangzhou city intermediate people  on  related 400000  yuan  compensation for  divorce  to  retrial  verdict  .due to  the  presence of  family violence  court finally  according to the agreement  is greater than the  fault,  legal  principle,  judgment  in accordance with the agreement of  400000 yuan of  compensation for  her  husband  .
ms. a  didn  experience  domestic violence  ,although  had  signed the  agreement  husband and wife  agreed  compensation  ,but in the  lawsuit  ,was  liquidated damages  amount  has  become the focus of  .
ms. a and  mr. z  in 2005  registration of marriage  ,marriage,  two people  signed the  agreement  couple  ,which  reads:  the  husband and wife  both parties through friendly consultations  ,in  equality  ,voluntary premise  ,the signing of this  agreement  .
the couple  agreed in the  common  life,  be loyal to one another  ,mutual respect  ,equality  ,harmony  ,safeguard  civilized marriage and family relations  ,family,  spouse  ,children,  moral values and  a sense of family responsibility  .
agreement stipulated explicitly  as follows: first  ,personal property  :economic  independent  marriage  ,renew  period,  both the  salary  ,bonus  ,welfare  ,production  ,operating income  of  all individuals  .
two  ,common property  :using  both the name  to open a bank  account  for the  total  pipe  joint property  .three  ,debt  :premarital  debts  each bear  ;married  debt  ,signed by both parties  ,shared responsibility;  unilateral  signature  ,signature  alone  by  .
in four  ,according to the  marriage law  stipulates that the forty-sixth  :bigamy  ,skull car accessoriesman was stabbed to death at the trial game account theft ne,having a spouse  cohabiting with another  ,the implementation of  domestic violence  ,abuse and  the desertion of one family member  and other  circumstances  ,lead to divorce  ,have the mistake side  must  pay compensation  without  fault  ,the amount of  a one-time payment of 400000  yuan  .
400000  compensation  exaggerated  ?after marriage,  ms. a and  mr. z  because of economic problems  occur frequently  contradictory  ,mr. z  to  ms. zhang  moved  several  hand  .in december 4, 2007,  mr.
z  a  lady  playing  minor injuries  .mr. z  to be  guangzhou  yuexiu district court  sentenced  to  crime of intentional injury  surveillance for six months  .because of unbearable  family violence  ,ms.
a  finally  asked for a divorce,  and claims that  mr z  should be in accordance with the  marital  agreement  agreement  should  pay 400000 yuan  .in 2008,  guangzhou city,  yuexiu court of first instance  thinks  ,according to the  marriage law of the prc  the forty-sixth regulation,  the implementation of  domestic violence led to the divorce  ,the innocent party  youquan  damages  .
the man  with  the woman  compensation  .due to the family  violence involving  personal relationship  ,so  considering the  amount of compensation  should be combined with  the victim    damages  ,injuring party  damage  behavior  ,injuring party  property situation  into consideration,  and should not  only  to the two sides signed the  agreement  husband and wife  shall prevail  .
in this case,  ms. a  most  heavy  one  injury  by the identification of  composing a slight wound  ,if  fully in accordance with the  agreement  husband and wife  agreed 400000  yuan  compensation  ,apparently with  ms.
a  damage effects  ,mr. z  damage  behavior and  the status of the property  not to suit,  also against  personal injury  and loss  equivalent  principle  ,considering a  lady  actual  injury  ,mr. z  damage  behavior and  the status of the property  ,therefore  ,as appropriate,  ordered  mr.
z  compensation  ms. a  damages of 50000 dollars  ,granting two  divorce  .retrial  recognized  marital  agreement  valid  after judgment  ,two average per capita  to appeal to the guangzhou  intermediate people  ,upheld  the  results  obtained  .
to this end,  ms. a  to  guangdong  province procuratorate  for  protest  ,guangdong  province  civil protest  ,the guangzhou intermediate people  retrial  of the case  .in 2011,  the guangzhou city intermediate people  for retrial  ,mr z  and  ms a  in april 16, 2006 signed the  agreement  husband and wife  ,the parties are  the true meaning  ,does not violate the  national laws  ,regulations of the  mandatory provisions  ,transformers car accessories,shall be deemed to be  valid  .
both parties shall,  in accordance with the contract  to fulfill  their respective rights and obligations  .secondly  ,the supreme people  on the application of    marriage law of the people    interpretation of several issues  (  a  )  the twenty-eighth regulation:  marriage  law forty-sixth stipulation  damages  ,including  material damages and compensation for moral damage  .
involving  the spirit damage compensate  ,supreme people  about determination civil  right infringement spirit damage compensate responsibility  to explain a number of problems  of the  relevant provisions  .
from mr. z  and  ms. a  signed the  agreement  husband and wife    ,the two sides agreed  to 400000 yuan  compensation  ,contains  material damages and compensation for moral damage  .the  verdict will be  400000 yuan  compensation for jin jun  as  compensation for spiritual damage  ,then  found  excessive amounts  ,biased  .
in third  ,mr. z  to ms. a  repeated  domestic violence  ,has reached  the  level  of criminal  ,to  ms. a  physical and mental health  have  caused serious  damage  ,even with the  physical damage to  the principle of profit and loss rather  ,agreed 400000  yuan  compensation  is not  obviously too high  .
in fourth  ,mr. z  as a  person with full capacity for civil conduct  ,the  agreement  husband and wife  agreed contents  should be clear  ,for breach of  agreement  should be  foreseeable  consequence responsibility  ,to  assume the  compensation  economic  ability  should be  considered  ,it should be  their actions bear  corresponding consequence  liability  .
in fifth  ,mr. z  in the  second  period  ,were not  on  the amount of compensation is  challenged,  also did not  put forward to adjust  ,the  judgment will be  400000 yuan  compensation  for 50000 yuan adjustment  according to inadequate  .
to sum up  ,the retrial  supports  ms a  claims 400000 yuan  lawsuit  .the  judges commented  damage compensation  should include material  and  spirit of the guangzhou  city intermediate people  supervision tribunal  judge  the analysis thinks  ,the  focus of controversy  is  the couple  agreed 400000  yuan of  divorce damage  compensation  is too high  ?this relates to  the divorce fault compensation  and how to determine  the  nature of  the divorce fault compensation  amount of questions  .
the system of compensation for divorce damage  is the foreign  relative law  generally  set  a system  ,the french civil code  ,the swiss civil code  ,the mexico civil code  ,all the provisions,  aims to  protect  the injured party and  the interests of the weak  in marriage  family law  ,realize the  justice principle in  and support the  protection of the weak  principle  .
china  marriage law  provisions of the  domestic violence  a  need for  damages  ,which involves  the spirit damage compensate  ,supreme people  about determination civil  right infringement spirit damage compensate responsibility  to explain a number of problems  of the  relevant provisions  .
it is  explicitly stipulated in the law  of  divorce fault compensation  case  ,the parties  have  stipulated in  the case can be directly  used  .ms. a  and  mr. z  has been previously  agreed in the agreement,  such as the emergence of  marriage law  stipulates that the forty-sixth  four kinds of  circumstances  ,lead to divorce  ,have the mistake side  must be  without  fault party  to pay compensation  ,the amount of 400000 yuan  .
in this way  will be  the amount of compensation  to be clear  .according to the agreement  is greater than the  statutory  principle,  under normal circumstances should  give priority to the application of  agreement between parties  .
and according to the  marriage law of the judicial interpretation  ,the  compensation  actually contains  material damages and compensation for moral damage  .in this case  the husband  to his wife  lady  z  a  implementation of family  violence  causes the latter to  compose a slight wound  ,if  only consider  minor  physical impairment  ,400000 yuan of  compensation  may be  too high  ,which is  a  trial of  adjustment  compensation  as the main factors to consider  .
however  ,despite the  body  physical damage  ,ms. a  also  suffered from mental  damage  .this kind of spirit  damage  except for  visible damage  leads to  mental distress  ,more  based on the  couple  of the personal  and  intimate  relationship  suffered  mental attack  and  heart  trauma  .
thus  ,the  compensation for divorce damage  ,the court cannot  machinery for  personal injury  and  equal  principle  ,but should consider the  party to suffer  physical  and moral damage  ,and  as a measure of  the  amount of compensation  shall be  obtained  .
this  case retrial  is based on this  consideration  and  revision  .400000  compensation  is not  obviously too high  supervision tribunal  judge thinks,  about determination civil  right infringement spirit damage compensate resp